I vote for Downtown_evilmelon_v1 because I think it would suite the community better. It would be hella more fun than downtown_v4_exl. Not to mention it's got a hospital, nuclear bunker for the mayor, bank vault in the bunker, and all this nice stuff.
rp_downtown_v4_exl:
Pros:
Common map
Everyone knows it and generally likes it
Not too complicated, very simple
Easy to find people and bases
Very nice neighborhood with dem houses/mansions
Cons:
Too cliché of a map
Too simple
Not much to do
Gets boring after awhile
rp_bangclaw:
Pros:
Very big
Epic desert base area
Huge complex awesome sewers
Very nice layout and open spaced
Offers a bunch of nice areas fit for RP
Cons:
TOO FREAKEN BIG
TOO FREAKEN COMPLEX
So hard to find anybody
Easy for people to hide away in a corner room and afk print and fap, neglecting RP
For our current server slots, it would be suicide to switch to this map
rp_downtown_evilmelon_v1:
Pros:
Totally epic
Very nice city layout and not too shabby of a sewer system as well
Small and complex, which makes it pretty simple
Integrated RP systems, such as a working bridge, elevators, shop alarms to call CP if thieves are raiding, working street lights, etc
Cons:
A few areas are too big/useless currently, specifically that small stretch of road under the tunnel. Nothing to do there but walk...or build a random base
It may be a bit too small for some people
Sewers sort of complex, but not as complex as rp_bangclaw